patell dot org

Cyrus R. K. Patell's Website

patell dot org
  • About
  • Articles
  • Books
  • Talks
  • Teaching
  • Current Projects
  • CHAL
  • Favorite Posts
September 17, 2008 by Cyrus Patell

Evil, Choice and Rationalism

The subjects of my second Con West class on Zoroastrianism are going to be Zoroastrianism’s approach to the problem of evil and its stress on the importance of free choice. I’ll most likely be using excerpts from the Gathas (included in the Zoroastrian liturgy known as the Yasna) to illustrate these points. I’ll probably also discuss two Zoroastrian symbols: the fire and the Faravahar.

Here’s an excerpt from one of this week’s readings, S. A. Nigosian’s The Zoroastrian Faith: Tradition and Modern Research that gets at these subjects:

According to ancient Iranian belief, Ahura Mazda was the wise lord, the all-knowing sky god, and the supreme creator. He was also intimately associated with truth, sovereignty, mysterious power, light, and sun. His nature was best expressed in the cult of fire (atar). The ritual attached to the sacred fire existed before Zoroaster, who adopted it and made it the outward symbol of truth (Yasna 43.9). In fact, Zoroaster taught that, for an individual to exercise free choice intelligently, Ahura Mazda gave his pure mind and his flaming fire of thought (Yasna 46.7). This fire was an enduring, blazing flame bringing clear guidance and joy to the true believer but destruction to lovers of evil (Yasna 34.4). It was through the energy of fire that Ahura Mazda assigned judgment to truth-followers and to
evil-followers (Yasna 43.4, 47 6).

Zoroaster saw humanity divided into two opposing parties: the truth-followers (ashavant), who were just and god-fearing; and the evil-followers (dregvant), among whom were classed all evil rulers, evil-doers, evil-speakers, those of evil conscience, and evil-thinkers (Yasna 49.11). But this basic dualism that Zoroaster saw here and now on earth he projected to the whole cosmos. He came to see that this fundamental tension existed both in the material as well as in the spiritual spheres. Over against a transcendental good mind stood the evil mind; over against the good spirit stood the evil spirit; and so on. Yet, on every level, a choice had to be made. This insistence on freedom of choice was the marked characteristic of Zoroaster’s teaching. In fact, what stood out in Zoroaster’s principles was not the ethical dualism of good versus evil but the importance of the individual as an arbiter between them. Each individual was ultimately faced with making a choice between good and evil, truth and falsehood.

I think it’s that combination of ethical (not to mention cosmic) dualism and freedom of choice that interested Melville and led him to include Zoroastrianism in Moby-Dick. I’m looking forward to exploring that in greater detail this year than I’ve been able to in the past.

Today’s playlist: the Brazilian jazz man Eumir Deodata’s arrangement of “Also Sprach Zarathushtra”; U2, “The Unforgettale Fire”; and The Doors, “Light My Fire.”

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Bookmark and Share
Posted in Uncategorized and tagged with ConWest, Melville. RSS 2.0 feed.
« Rock and Hard Place
High Anxiety (I) »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Search This SIte

Recent Books

Follow cpatell on Twitter

Recent Posts

  • Star Wars and the Technophobic Imagination
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2012-01-15
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2011-12-04
  • On the Eve of National Day
  • We Do Have Weather

Archives

Categories

RSS Recently on PWHNY

  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2012-02-05
  • Networked New York
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2012-01-29
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2012-01-22
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2012-01-15

NYUAD Blogs

  • Abu Bhloggi
  • Abu Dhabi Eats
  • Desert Stars
  • Don't Panic
  • Flaubertish
  • Fronteras Mestizas
  • Journey to the Middle East
  • Life in My Shoes
  • Literatura en Cuentos Cortos
  • My Parallel Life on the Arabian Gulf
  • New York and Modernity (J-Term Course)
  • Peace, Love, and Camels
  • Salaam Blog
  • Searching for the Mad Ones
  • Sight Unseen
  • Tale of Three Cities
  • Unheard Sermon of a Lesser Scholar

Tech Sites

  • Engadget
  • Gizmodo
  • Tom's Hardware
  • Unofficial Apple Weblog

Recent Comments

  • Yara on First Day of Class
  • Brook on NYUAD Blogging
  • Dick Horwich on Being Associate Dean
  • Ellyn L. on L (Significant Birthday)
  • Patell and Waterman’s History of New York · Ten Years Later and Many Miles Away on 11-9-11

Archives

Recent Posts

  • Star Wars and the Technophobic Imagination
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2012-01-15
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2011-12-04
  • On the Eve of National Day
  • We Do Have Weather
  • Some Girls and the MXR Phase 90
  • The Week in Pictures
  • Happy Thanksgiving from Abu Dhabi
  • Twitter Weekly Updates for 2011-11-20
  • Galaxy’s Youngest Sith Lord

Search This Site

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

All content © 2012 by patell dot org. CRKP by Graph Paper Press.